Longer term outcome of cognitive-behavioural and psychodynamic psychotherapy in routine mental health care: Randomised controlled trial

Behaviour Research and Therapy

Volume 50, Issue 9, September 2012, Pages 580–587

ScienceDirect.com – Behaviour Research and Therapy – Longer term outcome of cognitive-behavioural and psychodynamic psychotherapy in routine mental health care: Randomised controlled trial.

• Birgit Watzke^a, , ,
• Heinz Rüddel^b,
• Ralph Jürgensen^b,
• Uwe Koch^a,
• Levente Kriston^a,
• Barbara Grothgar^b,
• Holger Schulz^a

• ^a Department of Medical Psychology, University Medical Center Hamburg-Eppendorf, Germany
• ^b St. Franziska-Stift, Bad Kreuznach, Germany

• Abstract

  We investigated the comparative effectiveness of cognitive-behavioural (CBT) and psychodynamic therapy (PDT) under clinically representative conditions as a subtrial of a prior study (Watzke et al., 2010, BJP). A consecutive sample of 147 patients with common mental disorders was randomised to either CBT or PDT in routine mental health care. In a primary per-protocol analysis patients randomised to CBT had a significantly better longer term outcome in the primary outcome symptom severity (General Severity Index of the SCL-14;p = .001; partial η² = 0.073) as well as in health related quality of life (Mental Component Summary of the SF-8; p = .013; partial η² = .041) and concerning interpersonal issues (Inventory of Interpersonal Problems, IIP-C; p = .001; partial η² = .070) 6 months after treatment than patients randomised to PDT. These results could be confirmed in intention-to-treat analyses (n = 180) suggesting that there was no substantial attrition bias due to drop outs at the follow-up assessment. Thus, the so called equivalence outcome paradox was not replicated in this study.